Amartya Sen’s critique of Samuel Huntington’s “Clash of civilisations”
Published by March 4th, 2007 in Human rights and Podcasts & webcasts. 1 CommentThe argument that Sen makes is complex and I will not attempt to recap them here. But as a pointer, I’ll just mention that this talk is based on his book “Identities and Violence”. Sen questions the notion of Clash of civilisation by Samuel Huntington from different dimensions. He questions if any group of people can be neatly identified as a “civilization”, if animosity has to be the basis of difference and if Huntington’s identification of charecteristics of Western or Islamic civilisation are defendable.
Given Sen’s background he draws heavily from Indian history. But he also makes referneces to Arab world, Chinese history and annecdotes from other places in the world. Sen argues that each of us has multiple identities and commitments and makes a powerful case for a peaceful coexistance of diverse people.
The lecture was delivered at UCSC. To see the webcast, click here. To see another talk on this topic by Edward Said (again in University of California, but a different campus) click here.
Related posts:
- Best international news programmes: A list An effort to build a list of good international news programmes to get news from diverse perspectives Over the last few years, I have developed...
- Podcasts & webcasts of talks, courses, and informative shows This page contains my bookmarks on audio and video materials available online. These include lectures by famous people, good talks on a variety of subjects,...
- Big list of Webcasts online: Documentaries, talks, television & other videos This is a huge list of lists of webcast sources. Contains the best academic webcasts as well as online television, documentaries, etc. The list below...
- Useful links on Right to Information: Research, campaigns, tools, etc. This page contains academic resources, links to campaigns using right to information, tools, and other resources on the right to information. Updated as and when...
- Right to food: Useful links The following is an assortment of links on the right to food including photo albums, articles, useful websites, data sources, research materials, news articles, etc....
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Powered by Wordpress & K2 | All rights reserved | Copyright CC | 2006
Though the point of multiple identities can never be denied, yet the arguments of Samuel Huntington in his ‘Clash of Civilzation’ equally can not be ignored.What originated from the Crusades and elongated throughout the course of clashes between Christian Europe and the Islamic Near-East and Middle-East has taken a new turn with the Pan-Islamic objective of transforming Christian Europe to a Dar-ul-Islam by a steadfast pursuit of conversion of as many Christians as possible to Islam and by increasing the number of marriages of Christian women with the Muslims. European secularism has provided the best opprtunity for the expansion of Islam in Europe and the same is the case of America; and this is a point ignored by both Huntington and Sen. In coming one hundred years Europe may become an Islamic continent; therefore, the clash is now under the carpet, Amartya can not see it.